Silage Competition Awards
Silage Competition – February 2022
Silage Competition Results
The AgriScot Silage Competition, judged as part of the special awards ceremony held at Ingliston recently, rewarded quality silages produced on farms as far apart as Stromness and Stranraer.
One hundred and forty silage analysis reports were submitted to the competition, across dairy, beef & sheep, big bale and young farmers classes. Samples of the silages with the best analysis were collected for live assessment by the competition judges at the AgriScot awards ceremony.
Competition organiser, Andrew Best, of Watson Seeds (also the prize sponsor) stated:
“We were delighted with another healthy entry of 140 silage analysis, and also the geographical spread of those entries. I think it’s a testament to the competition that we had winners from Wigtownshire to Orkney. The standard of the competition was very good, which is encouraging in the current climate of high feed and fertiliser costs; maximising the full potential of a grass ley to achieve target dry matters and high ME and crude protein levels is essential for livestock farms.”
“Across the competition, the average analysis of the silages was 33.44DM, 11.24 ME, 13.76P with pH 4.3.”
“I would like to congratulate all of our winners and thank everyone who supported the competition.”
First place in the Big Bale class was awarded to Alex Sanger of Rosemount Farms, Montrose with a sample of 30.6DM, 12.2ME, 13.1P and pH 3.9. Willie Cruickshank of West Mains, Dumfries and Gordon Nicholson, Welton Farm, Blairgowrie, were second and third respectively.
First prize in the hotly contested Dairy Clamp class was awarded to a 37.6DM, 12.3ME, 18.2P, pH4.4 produced by Daniel Ritch on his Brettobreck Farm, Stromness. Organisers believe that this is the furthest north this prize has ever gone!
Second and third prizes in the Dairy Clamp class were awarded to silages from the more traditional dairy heartlands of Dumfriesshire, with Willie Young, Waterside Mains, Thornhill taking second and John Mackie, Dalfibble, Dumfries third.
South West Scotland also dominated in the Beef & Sheep classes and in the Young Farmers class.
First in the Beef & Sheep was awarded to a silage – 27.6DM, 12.3ME, 15.4P, pH4.1 – from Adam McIntosh, Achneel, Stranraer. Second prize was Sam Carlisle, North Darvargal, Dumfries with Adam Wardrop of Knockterra Farming Co, Cumnock in third.
Reuben Inman, of Kilnknowe, Lockerbie won the Young Farmers class with a 35.1DM, 11.5ME,16.1P pH4.1 sample. Upper Nisbet, Jedburgh was the home of the second placed silage in this class, produced by brothers Harry & Andrew Neill. Nigel Boyd from Rockallhead, Dumfries was third.
The silage analysis reports were shortlisted by Hugh McClymont, SAC Crichton Royal Farm who was joined by RHASS Chairman, Bill Gray for the live judging.
2020 Silage Competition
It was a virtual judging experience for the AgriScot silage competition this year, once again placed by SRUC’s Crichton Royal farm manager, Hugh McClymont.
Sponsored by Watson Seeds, the classes were judged within the college’s farm complex and the winners announced from there. The judging process is availabe to watch here on YouTube.
Big bale silage
Entrant Dry matter ME D-value Protein
1. J McDonald 42.6 12.9 80 13.1
2. Rednock Estate 84.2 11.8 73.9 15.8
3. W and S Thomson 20.3 12.1 75.8 13.9
YF dairy silage
1. S Van der Spruit 36.6 11.9 74.2 18.5
2. A Gemmell 26.0 12.0 75.0 13.5
3. F Thomson 30.7 12.1 75.8 14.1
Kirkton of Beath
YF beef silage
1. A Neill 28.7 11.4 71.5 12.6
2. C Marshall 35.4 11.0 68.7 12.6
3. R Brown 32.7 11.1 69.6 12.8
Beef clamp silage
1. R Black 30.6 12.3 77.0 15
2 G Lofthouse 22.5 12.1 75.7 18.3
3. A Martin 34.5 11.9 74.3 13.7
Dairy clamp silage
1. T Ralston 33.4 12.4 76.9 16.9
2. C Stalker 36.1 12.2 75.9 14.8
3. R Murdoch 30.9 12.1 75.9 17.7