Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year

If you would like to nominate a farm for Scottish Dairy Farm Of The Year please email your nomination to . Applications must be submitted by 20th September 2019.  The winner will be announced at AgriScot on the 20th November.

Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year 2018


An East Ayrshire family run dairy farm has been awarded the prestigious Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year 2018 title.

The award is part of a series of farm of the year awards presented at AgriScot, the farm business event, held at Ingliston, Edinburgh on 21st November.

Laigh Tarbeg farm at Cumnock, which is owned and operated by the Alistair and Hugh Watson and family, was awarded the dairy farm of the year title after seeing off stiff competition from 2 other finalist farms.

Convenor of the award, and AgriScot Director, Gilmour Lawrie, himself an award-winning dairy farmer commented:

“Laigh Tarbeg farm, and its resident herd of dairy cows, are a credit to the Watson family and their staff.”

“I visited the farm alongside the 2 independent assessors, and we were all seriously impressed. Firstly, and most importantly on any dairy farm, are the cows. We saw healthy, contented cows on all 3 finalist farms and this was certainly evident at Laigh Tarbeg.”

“The implementation of new technology and innovation was what made Laigh Tarbeg really stand out from the others.”

“An acute shortage of skilled, willing labour is being felt across all sectors of agriculture and this is only likely to get worse. Laigh Tarbeg is a case study in how innovative technology, such as robotic milking, feeders and shed scrapers, can be used to take the drudgery out of routine chores and free up valuable labour for more lucrative responsibilities whilst also helping to achieve a better work/life balance.”

“We were also impressed by the breeding and replacement policy at Laigh Tarbeg. Rather than breed replacements on-farm, the Watson’s buy in their heifers freshly calved. With no need to breed dairy animals, this then means that cows can be inseminated with beef semen to produce higher value beef animals for sale.”

“Ultimately this policy also allows the Laigh Tarbeg team to concentrate on looking after their cows and producing milk, without the hassle of rearing and running replacements.”

Commenting on the award, Hugh Watson said:

“We’re obviously delighted to win the SDFOTY Award, especially because it reflects all Alistair’s hard work. There were a number of good dairy units throughout Scotland not nominated, so we were pleased not only to be nominated, but to have won.” 

“Enthusiasm from Young Farmers in Scotland is second to none, as is the tech and cowman-ship within the industry, so standing here today with the prize is a great honour.”

The Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year award is sponsored by CowAlert, the fertility, health and welfare monitoring system for dairy cows developed by Edinburgh based animal technologists, Ice Robotics.

Willie Cuthbertson of Ice Robotics commented:

“We’re pleased to once again sponsor this award, and think the results speak for themselves. Congratulations to the Watsons on being named this year’s AgriScot Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year.”

The AgriScot farm of the year awards aim to showcase best practice and innovative thinking to the wider industry, as Gilmour Lawrie concluded:

“We tweaked the Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year award this year, to run it in the same nomination led format as our other awards.”

“I am delighted that the result was 3 finalist farms, and ultimately the award recipient, who are exceptional examples of the best of Scottish dairying.”

“Laigh Tarbeg can stand proudly alongside our previous Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year title holders as a beacon of best practice.”


The Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year Award is kindly sponsored by:

Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year 2017

Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year 2017 went to the team from Meldrum Farm.


MELDRUM farm, Blair Drummond, has claimed the much sought-after title of Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year at this year’s AgriScot.

Winning dairy farmer David Hamilton, of Wm. Hamilton and Son, milks 826 Holsteins, with a production average of 11955kg and a first calving age of 23.5 months, said: “We are delighted to have won. We have an excellent team and it’s great for them to be rewarded in this way. We had incredibly strong opposition and so a win amongst such good company really helps us to continue striving to improve what we do and keep our focus on the future.”

Judging the award, which was sponsored by Ice Robotics, was Donald Millar from Trailflat farm, Lochmaben, who was a member of last year’s winning team and a previous winner at AgriScot of the business person of the year. Mr Millar was given the task of selecting the top farms from over 800 across the country and judging the final 20 and then to the final four.

He based his selection on items that related to long lasting happy cows, efficiency of production and profit such as calving age, calving index, yield and quality of milk produced, somatic cell counts and the percent of lactations that were five or over. During the farm visits, Donald studied nutrition, calf rearing, cow comfort and many other things relating to good management, including sire selection criteria.

Mr Millar remarked on the high quality standards involved in this year’s category and what underlying features made Meldrum the eventual winner: “All the top twenty were a great credit to Scottish dairy farming and the top four were outstanding in every respect, but I chose Meldrum as they had every facet of costs and income under control during a very difficult year with great calf rearing and cow comfort management. They had outstanding forage quality with the multi cut silage system. They also had a very healthy herd and great credit for allowing school children and veterinary students to visit the farm to encourage the next generation.”


The Scottish Dairy Farm of the Year Award is kindly sponsored by:

Sign up today for free and be the first to get notified on new updates.
* indicates required